The Right Conservative News Site | Right Side News

Switch to desktop Register Login

Climate Gate 2 Update November 27, 2011

by Ken Haapla, SEPP
Climategate II:
Early this week another batch of emails from the Climatic Research Unit (CRU) at the University of East Anglia started appearing on the internet, apparently first identified by Jeff Id and his Air Vent blog. Over the week it became increasingly evident that the many, if not all, are authentic and were copied at the same time as the first batch of emails that were released two years ago, leading to Climategate.

climatology_dees_climategateThe University immediately denounced the leak and called it a theft, without substantiation. It could be a hacker or someone very familiar with the CRU. The situation is somewhat analogous to what became known as the Pentagon Papers. Secretly started as a history of the Vietnam War by the Secretary of Defense McNamara during the Johnson administration, these papers were highly critical of how four administrations misled the public as to their intent in Vietnam and were especially critical of the Johnson Administration. The papers were classified top secret.

Without authorization, Daniel Ellsberg copied the papers and subsequently gave the copies to the New York Times, which began publishing excerpts, terming them a leak rather than a theft. TWTW will follow the example set by the NYT, and call the Climategate emails a leak.

As with the original, Climategate II involves email correspondence among various individuals, the "team," who are highly influential in preparing the reports of the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) as well as other reports such as those by the US Climate Change Science Program (CCSP) and a climate change report by the US National Research Council (NRC).

Global warming alarmists and their supporters in the press have tried to down play the leak by claiming they contain nothing new. Certainly, there is nothing new in the methods, but Climategate II gives additional detail on how members of the team misled the public and manipulated the contents of so-called scientific reports. In the links provided below, and in links that can be sourced from them, many examples can be found.

Among efforts to mislead the public as to the certainty of the global warming science, both Roger Pielke, Sr. and Roger Pielke, Jr, on their respective web sites, explain how research was dropped from important documents. Pielke Sr. explains how the NRC, Ben Santer (US Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory) and Phil Jones (CRU) inappropriately interfered with much needed further research to reconcile surface temperature trends with tropospheric temperature trends.

Roger Pielke, Jr. explains how his research was excluded from the IPCC Fourth Assessment Report (AR4). What is particularly ludicrous is the charge by Jones and Kevin Trenberth (US National Center for Atmospheric Research) that the Pielke, et al, scientific paper was political. The IPCC is a political organization with scientific pretentions. Lead chapter authors of the IPCC calling a scientific paper political is illustrative of how the team twists language as the need requires.

The emails show the team was very aware that the warming of the troposphere above the tropics was not occurring as predicted in the models. This has been called the distinct human fingerprint. Ben Santer, et al, have attempted to cover up this disparity by expanding the error bounds of measurements, but their study is vague, at best. On November 14, 2011 Ben Santer participated in a public briefing of Representatives Ed Markey and Harry Waxman. Santer specifically discussed human fingerprints in global warming but failed to discuss the disparity between models and measurements over the tropics. Apparently, at least some members of the team cannot be relied upon to accurately present the state of the science to members of Congress.

Download Full PDF of this Report  |  Redundant File

Given the events this week, it may be appropriate to re-read John Brignell's essay "How we know they know they are lying:"

Please links under "Climategate Continued," "Suppressing Scientific Inquiry" and Singer June, 2011


Commentary on Climate Science: Following release of Climategate II emails, Roy Spencer explains why he believes the major source of the problem, in the US, is with the failure of Congress to fund the opposing point of view - that the causes of climate change are mostly natural. If this was done, the IPCC would be subject to very strong scientific criticism and perhaps science would advance rather than be mired in the notion that the principal cause of global warming is human emissions of carbon dioxide. Members of SEPP have mentioned such a view to funding authorities, with no avail.

Some may find this view a bit cynical. They may reflect on past generations of government funded scientists, who considered scientific integrity paramount, and desire a return to such a view.

Yet, during the debates on the adoption of the US Constitution the wisdom of a more centralized government was intensely argued. Even those who supported a stronger central government recognized that power attracts the ambitious, and for that reason proposed pitting power against power. Considering the size of many science research budgets, the $31 Billion the GAO has identified as going to climate science alone from 1993 through Fiscal Year 2010 is enough to attract the ambitious.

Tim Ball and Roger Pielke, Sr, have provided different commentary. Although not specifically commenting on Climategate II, Ball points out that the IPCC was not founded to understand the causes of global warming / climate change but to discover human causes. The failure to establish a baseline of natural causes has led to the willingness of the IPCC to emphasize only the data that supports human causes and largely ignore natural causes. Carbon dioxide emissions became the culprit.

In commenting on an article in Physics Today, Pielke Sr. emphasizes that the increasing vagueness of the language used by the global warming alarmists leads to obfuscation of scientific endeavors. He distinguishes between human caused climate change and global warming caused by human emissions of carbon dioxide.

In a paper released about the same time as the Climategate II emails, Ross McKitrick discusses what he thinks needs to be changed in the IPCC process before the IPCC can be considered a reliable source for science. He provides case studies of flaws in entire IPCC process. No doubt, Climategate II will further support his contentions.

Please see links under "Challenging the Orthodoxy," "Communicating Better to the Public - Exaggerate or Obfuscate," and "Seeking a Common Ground."


Number of the Week: 5,300. According to reports, that is approximately the number of emails released in Climategate II. No doubt, many are ordinary correspondence, but some are revealing. Also according to reports, over 200,000 are encrypted behind a very difficult to crack code.


Correction and Amplification: TWTW reader Sonja A. Boehmer-Christiansen corrected a statement in the December 12 TWTW: "Investigative reporting, such as Donna Laframboise's exposé of the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), needed to be done years ago." Such exposés have appeared in the literature since the 1990s, but largely ignored. She wishes Donna Laframboise better luck than she and her colleagues have experienced. As always, TWTW greatly appreciates corrections and amplifications.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

For the numbered articles below please see this week's TWTW at:
The articles are at the end of the pdf.

1. A Bad Year for Climate Alarmism
By Fred Singer, Letter to Washington Post, Nov 19, 2011, Not published

2. Lisa Jackson's Freudian Slip
An unintentionally revealing interview from the EPA chief.
Editorial, WSJ, Nov 22, 2011

3. U.K. Report Gives Clean-Energy Costs
By James Herron, WSJ, Nov 24, 2011

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Climategate Continued
Welcome to the ClimateGate FOIA Grepper!!! [H/t Jo Nova]...
[SEPP Comment: A searchable service for both Climategate I & II emails.]

Release of climate emails - November 2011
Press Release, University of East Anglia, Nov 22, 2011

Climategate 2.0 emails - They're real and they're spectacular!
By News Staff, WUWT, Nov 22, 2011

Private Expressions of Uncertainty
By Steve McIntyre, Climate Audit, Nov 23, 2011
One of the main themes of the emails is scientists admitting problems privately that they did not clearly admit in public. Ross has emailed me a few starters. Again no editorializing, just listing.

A Somewhat Late Response to Schneider
By Ross McKitrick, Climate Audit, Nov 25, 2011

A new Climategate scandal, familiar cast of characters
In the wake of Climategate 2.0, action on the IPCC is more needed than ever
By Terence Corcoran, Financial Post, Nov 22, 2011

Climategate, Part Duh!
By Alan Caruba, Warning Signs, Nov 22, 2011

Suppressing Scientific Inquiry
An E-Mail Communication Between Phil Jones and Ben Santer Indicating Inappropriate Behavior By The US National Research Council
By Roger Pielke, Sr, Pielke Climate Science, Nov 25, 2011
This is a remarkable e-mail since it indicates that the NRC was in collusion with Phil Jones to suppress issues that I brought up as lead author on the CCSP chapter 6. Chapter 6 was tasked to focus on what further research issues need to be explored to reconcile surface and tropospheric temperature trends.

FOIA2011 on The Shameful Paper
By Roger Pielke Jr, His Blog, Nov 23, 2011
there is a 2005 exchange between Trenberth and Phil Jones about this paper which shows them deciding together to exclude the paper from the IPCC for "political" reasons, and it was indeed excluded.

Challenging the Orthodoxy
IPCC Climate Claims Falsified by 2010 Record High CO2 Levels.
By Tim Ball, His Blog, Nov 23, 2011

Climate Sensitivity Estimated from Temperature Reconstructions of the Last Glacial Maximum
Andreas Schmittner1,*, Nathan M. Urban2, Jeremy D. Shakun3, Natalie M. Mahowald4, Peter U. Clark5, Patrick J. Bartlein6, Alan C. Mix1, Antoni Rosell-Melé7, Science, Nov 24, 2011

Climate change fears 'have been exaggerated' and doomsday predictions are overestimates, say scientists
By Fiona Macrae, Daily Mail, Nov 25, 2011 [H/t Catherine French]

Global Warming Forecasts 'Exaggerated'
By David Whitehouse, The Observatory, Nov 25, 2011

CO2 climate sensitivity 'overestimated'
By Jennifer Carpenter, BBC News, Nov 25, 2011
"One should be very careful about using cold climates to [construct] the future," he added.
[SEPP Comment: For the last 2.5 million years the dominant climate has been ice ages interrupted by brief warm periods. The evidence such cold periods will not occur in the future is distinctly lacking.]

Defending the Orthodoxy
China to call for extension of Kyoto at climate talks
By Staff Writers, AFP, Nov 22, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Why not? It costs China nothing, while thanks to Kyoto restrictions more European businesses are building facilities in China.]

A bad month for climate-change skeptics
Editorial, Washington Post, Nov 18, 2011
[SEPP Comment: See Article # 1, Fred Singer's rebuttal to this article which the Washington Post did not publish, before Climategate II.]

Carbon surge to test resolve at UN climate talks
By Staff Writers, AFP, Nov 21, 2011

Bridging the Emissions Gap to Meet 2-Degree Target Doable
By Staff Writers, UNEP, Nov 23, 2011 [H/t Scientific Alliance]
[SEPP Comment: Typical propaganda photo included.]

Questioning the Orthodoxy
Rajendra Pachauri - The Little Man Who Told Big Whoppers
By Donna Laframbose, NFC, Nov 19, 2011

The Two Degrees of Warming Threshold is Political, Not Scientific
By Greg Pollowitz, Planet Gore, Nov 18, 2011 [H/t Timothy Wise]

Pachauri Interviewed by Pretend Journalist
By Donna Laframboise, NFC, Nov 20, 2011
[SEPP Comment: A puff piece by the Natural Resources Defense Council becomes an article in the Guardian newspaper with major inaccuracies.]

Questioning European Green
Emission Controls: The Exodus Begins
By Peter C. Glover, Energy Tribune, Nov 23, 2011

Green energy could trigger 'catastrophic' blackouts
'Unstable' renewable energy sources increase the risk of 'supra-regional' electricity blackouts with multi-billion pound consequences, insurance giant Allianz has warned
By Matthew Holehouse, Telegraph, UK, Nov 23, 2011 [H/t GWPF]

Big GWPF Success: British Gas Promises Transparent Energy Bills
By Staff Writers, GWPF, Nov 24, 2011

Expanding the Orthodoxy
UBC researchers provide recommendations for $100 billion in annual climate change aid
By Staff Writers, SPX, Nov 21, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Going for the Gold!]

Climate Change Adaptation: Federal Efforts to Provide Information Could Help Government Decision Making
GAO-12-238T November 16, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Given the alarmist nature of the Federal government supported climate science, poor decisions are the likely result.]

Climate policies can help resolve energy security and air pollution challenges
By Staff Writers, SPX, Nov 21, 2011

Problems within the Orthodoxy
Obama Blocks $100 Billion Climate Fund
By Pilita Clark and Javier Blas, Financial Times, UK, Nov 24, 2011
[SEPP Comment: May be premature.]

Showdown nears for climate deal
Expected debate over Kyoto Protocol threatens to stall progress on other fronts.
By Jeff Tollefson, Nature, Nov 22, 2011

Rich nations 'give up' on new climate treaty until 2020
Ahead of critical talks and despite pledge for new treaty by 2012, biggest economies privately admit likelihood of long delay
By Fiona Harvey, Guardian, UK, Nov 20, 2011

Seeking a Common Ground
Climategate 2.0: Bias in Scientific Research
By Roy Spencer, His Blog, Nov 23, 2011

Fix it or fold it
If the IPCC's flaws can't be corrected, we should leave
By Ross McKitrick, Financial Post, Can, Nov 22, 2011
[SEPP Comment: See full paper at link below.]

What Is Wrong with the IPCC
Proposals for a Radical Reform
By Ross McKitrick, GWPF, 2011, ISBN: 978-0-9566875-4-8

Climategate is a distraction
By Martin Livermore, Scientific Alliance, [Nov 25, 2011]

Communicating Better to the Public - Exaggerate or Obfuscate?
Public Misperception About Scientific Agreement on Global Warming Undermines Policy Support
By Staff Writers, SPX, Nov 25, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Perhaps the Center for Climate Change Communication should establish clear, precise definitions before conducting or commenting on political polls.]

Communicating the science of climate change
Richard C. J. Somerville and Susan Joy Hassol, Physics Today, Oct. 2011 [H/t Wally Manheimer]
It is urgent that climate scientists improve the ways they convey their findings to a poorly informed and often indifferent public.
[SEPP Comment: See link below.]

Comments On The Physics Today Article "Communicating The Science Of Climate Change" By Richard C. J. Somerville and Susan Joy Hassol
By Roger Pielke, Sr, Pielke Climate Science, Nov 22, 2011
This article is a tutorial on advocacy of a perspective on policy that really should not be in a journal such as Physics Today. It is an example of a set of individuals using an article (not an op-ed) in a professional science journal to promote their particular views on policy.
[SEPP Comment: See link above.]

Greenhouse gases, water vapor and you
By Dean Kuipers, LA Times, Nov 18, 2011
So, when NOAA's Jim Butler confirmed in our previous post that carbon dioxide, nitrous oxide, methane, and two CFCs cause 95% of global warming, he meant that these five gases are at the root of a complex reaction that also involves water vapor and any number of other factors. [Emphasis added.]

Communicating Better to the Public - Make things up.
Bleak future for Bay area tidal marshes?
By Staff Writers, SPX, Nov 24, 2011

Models v. Observations
Separating signal and noise in climate warming
By Anne M Stark for LLNL News, SPX, Nov 21, 2011
The satellite data indicate that the lower troposphere has warmed by roughly 0.9 degrees Fahrenheit since the beginning of satellite temperature records in 1979. This increase is entirely consistent with the warming of Earth's surface estimated from thermometer records.
[SEPP Comment: Another misrepresentation of the satellite data.]

Another Excellent, Well-Explained Post By Bob Tisdale Titled "Satellite-Era SST Anomalies: Models Vs Observations Using Time-Series Graphs And 17-Year Trends"
By Roger Pielke, Sr, Nov 22, 2011
[SEPP Comment: So much for the new-found 17 year trend needed to show the difference between models and observations.]

 Measurement Issues
Important Paper "Remote Sensing Of The Urban Heat Island Effect Across Biomes In The Continental USA" By Imhoff Et Al 2011
By Roger Pielke, Sr, Pielke Climate Science, Nov 25, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Possibly challenging one of the BEST findings.]

Changing Weather
Even longtime Alaskans taken off guard by deep freeze
By Tim Mowry, Fairbanks News Miner, Nov 17, 2011 [H/t Gordon Fulks]

Protecting Houston from the next big hurricane
By Staff Writers, SPX, Nov 21, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Will environmental organizations permit such efforts to prevent human suffering, or will they sue under the National Environmental Policy Act to prevent such efforts as they successfully did in New Orleans.]

Changing Climate
The Odd Omission in IPCC's Summary for Policy Makers for SREX on Extreme Weather and Climatic Events
By Indur Goklany, WUWT, Nov 19, 2011
[SEPP Comment: See link below.]

Climate change means more frequent droughts and floods, U.N. panel says in report
By Juliet Eilperin, Washington Post, Nov 18, 2011 [H/t Best of the Web]
"The science is not getting more uncertain - it's actually getting more and more certain," she said. "It's getting in line with what people intuitively feel." Emphasis added.]
[SEPP Comment: Accompanied by a video: Japan's government gave journalists a tour of the country's tsunami-damaged nuclear power plant for the first time since the March 11 disaster as if the tsunami was a result of climate change.]

Global warming we can all cheer
By Matt Patterson, NY Post, Nov 18, 2011 [H/t Warren Wetmore]

Changing Seas
Rethinking the ocean's role in Pacific climate
By Staff Writers, SPX, Nov 22, 2011

Seaweeds threaten corals
Release chemicals that cause bleaching
By Indu Mathi S, Down to Earth, India, Nov 30, 2011

Changing Sea Ice
Study: Arctic ice melting 'unprecedented'
By Staff Writers, UPI, Nov 23, 2011
"Everything is trending up -- surface temperature, the atmosphere is warming, and it seems also that the ocean is warming and there is more warm and saline water that makes it into the Arctic,"
[SEPP Comment: Another 50 year trend! How does it compare with the Holocene Climate Optimum?]

Agriculture Issues & Fear of Famine
Drought-proof village in bone dry district
By Sarandha, Down to Earth, India, Nov, 18, 2011

Global commission charts pathway for achieving food security in face of climate change
By Staff Writers, SPX, Nov 24, 2011

The Future of Grapes
By Patrick Michaels, WCR, Nov 21, 2011
[SEPP Comment: There will always be wine.]

The Political Games Continue
U.S. Taxpayers No Longer Have To Fund Anti-American UNESCO
By Phyllis Schlafly, IBD, Nov 22, 2011
[SEPP Comment: A path to the future of the IPCC?]

Deconstructing GOP's climate contradictions
By Henry Waxman, Politico, Nov 13, 2011 [H/t Tom Waeghe]
But even as committee Republicans argue the science is unresolved, they have, with one exception, rejected repeated requests to bring scientists before the committee to educate members.
[SEPP Comment: For many years the committee hearings were stacked with alarmists paid by government entities to spread the alarm.]

Subsidies and Mandates Forever
U.S. Energy Subsidies: Wind and Solar Have No Argument
By Robert Bradley, IER, Nov 21, 2011

EIA Releases New Subsidy Report: Subsidies for Renewables increase 186 Percent
By Staff Writers, IER, Aug 3, 2011

Diesel: when bad policy makes for toxic hell
By Sunita Narain, Down to Earth, Nov 30, 2011
[SEPP Comment: A view from India.]

EPA and other Regulators on the March
EPA/DOT Admit - No, Boast - New Fuel Economy Standards Bypass Congress
By Marlo Lewis, Global, Nov 21, 2011
[SEPP Comment: No need for a Constitution here.]

EPA moves to require 'fracking' chemical info disclosure
By Ben Geman, The Hill, Nov 23, 2011
[SEPP Comment: The enviros ask, the EPA gives. It will be interesting to see if the resulting rules are another example of zealotry. See suggestions from Duke University below.]

Contractor Alleges Pressure to Alter Finding on Coal Rule's Cost in Jobs
By Ryan Tracy, WSJ, Nov 19, 2011
[SEPP Comment: May be behind a paywall.]

EPA delays rollout of refinery greenhouse gas rule
By Ben Geman, The Hill, Nov 21, 20112

Energy Issues
Chevron CEO: "The Imperative of Affordable Energy" (Moral substance trumps 'green' form)
By Robert Bradley Jr, Master Resource, Nov 25, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Energy must be affordable and reliable.]

Oil and Natural Gas - the Future or the Past?
Peak oil vanishes; peak green arrives
Peak oil theory and the green energy fad both arise from a failure to ­understand how markets work
By Peter Foster, Financial Post, Nov 22, 2011

Crude awakening
With new technology, experts imagine what was once unthinkable - making the US oil independent
By Brad Parks, NY Post, Nov 20, 2011 [H/t Warren Wetmore]

Saudis worry over North American shale oil surge
By Yadullah Hussain, Financial Post, Nov 21, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Recognize may be more accurate than worry.]

Duke study offers seven safeguards for hydraulic fracturing
By Staff Writers, SPX, Nov 21, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Appear to be reasonable, prudent steps that protect the public as well as possibly protect drillers against frivolous lawsuits.]

Administration's Control of Oil and Gas
Obama's Keystone Conundrum: Union Jobs Vs. Environmental Jabs
By Larry Bell, Forbes, Nov 22, 2011

Obama's Disastrous Energy Record
By Chad Stafko, American Thinker, Nov 25, 2011

Fracking halted in Wayne National Forest pending further study
By Kathy Thompson, Lancaster Eagle Gazette, Nov 16, 2011

Oil Spills & Consequences
Chevron blames Brazil oil spill on miscalculation
By Staff Writers, AFP, Nov 19, 2011

Chevron oil spill a wake-up call for Brazil: analysts
By Staff Writers, AFP, Nov 24, 2011

Nuclear Energy and Fears
One week to go for nuclear rover
By Staff Writers, WNN, Nov 18, 2011

Fukushima radiation 'mostly fell in sea': study
By Staff Writers, AFP, Nov 17, 2011

Driving on with Fukushima roadmap
By Staff Writers, WNN, Nov 17, 2011

Swiss nuclear shutdown to cost 16.8 billion euro
By Staff Writers, AFP, Nov 24, 2011
[SEPP Comment: In response to the tsunami that knocked out the cooling systems at Fukushima (the systems survived the earthquake). Entirely landlocked, Switzerland is not noted for tsunamis. Apparently the cost estimates do not address the cost of replacing the power generation lost.]

IAEA Issues New Report on Climate Change and Nuclear Power
Report Highlights Role of Nuclear in Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions
By Rodolfo Quevenco, IAE, Nov 25, 2011

Alternative, Green ("Clean") Energy
Chu doubles down on clean energy
By Andrew Restuccia, The Hill, Nov 18, 2011
[SEPP Comment: We only lost half the farm the first time, let's double the bet.]

Wind of change hitting renewable
By Bill Jamieson, Scotsman, Nov 24, 2011 [H/t Paul Chesser]

Wind farms are useless, says Duke
The Duke of Edinburgh has made a fierce attack on wind farms, describing them as "absolutely useless".
By Jonathan Wynne-Jones, Telegraph, UK, Nov 19, 2011 [H/t Mark Duchamp]

Google quits plans to make cheap renewable energy
By Alexei Oreskovic, Reuters, Nov 23, 2011 [H/t Debbie Wetlaufer]
[SEPP Comment: Perhaps Google realizes that Moore's Law does not necessarily apply to renewable energy and that making it cheaper than coal was more a marketing slogan than a technological possibility. Google had proposed massive financing of a very expensive electrical transmission system along the coast of the Mid-Atlantic States using power generated by off-shore turbines. That may be gone as well.]

Second-generation ethanol processing is cost prohibitive
By Staff Writers, SPX, Nov 23, 2011

Carbon Schemes
Wyoming CO2 Sequestration Project Falling Apart
By Michael J. Economides, Energy Tribune, Nov 21, 2011

Finally, the plan for the CCS revolution
Study reveals how to build a CO2 transport system for Europe
By Karel Beckman, European Energy Review, Nov 17, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Hope against experience.]

How CCS can transform our energy future
By Robin Mills, European Energy Review, Nov 21, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Make the cost of carbon dioxide emissions high enough, CCS becomes viable. Who cares if the economy goes bankrupt in the process?]

Review of Recent Scientific Articles by NIPCC
For a full list of articles see

Variation in Surface Air Temperature of China During the 20th Century
Reference: Soon, W., Dutta, K., Legates, D.R., Velasco, V. and Zhang, W. 2011. Variation in surface air temperature of China during the 20th century. Journal of Atmospheric and Solar-Terrestrial Physics 73: 2331-2344.
The empirically-based study of Soon et al. (2011), however, goes one step further than all previous studies of the subject by showing how the two empirical results shown in Figures 1 and 2 may be related to key meteorological phenomenon involving the so-called Asian-African westerly jets.

Earth's Marine Life Not Going "Quietly Into the Night" of Ocean Acidification
Reference: Hurd, C.L., Cornwall, C.E., Currie, K., Hepburn, C.D., McGraw, C.M., Hunter, K.A. and Boyd, P.W. 2011. Metabolically induced pH fluctuations by some coastal calcifiers exceed projected 22nd century ocean acidification: a mechanism for differential susceptibility? Global Change Biology 17: 3254-3262.

The Case for a Quasi Sixty-Year North Atlantic Temperature Oscillation
Reference: Mazzarella, A. and Scafetta, N. 2011. Evidences for a quasi 60-year North Atlantic Oscillation since 1700 and its meaning for global climate change. Theoretical and Applied Climatology: 10.1007/s00704-011-0499-4.

Old Growth Forests of Northeast China
Reference: Zhou, L., Dai, L., Wang, S., Huang, X., Wang, X., Qi, L., Wang, Q., Li, G., Wei, Y. and Shao, G. 2011. Changes in carbon density for three old-growth forests on Changbai Mountain, Northeast China: 1981-2010. Annals of Forest Science 68: 953-958.

Environmental Industry
Sierra Club Leader Will Step Down
By John Broder, NYT, Nov 18, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Since oil companies are funding some environmental groups, why not a bleach company?]

Wilderness Society cuts staff, citing weak economy
The prominent land preservation group lets 17% of its employees go as some multiyear donations end and spending is reduced.
By Bettina Baxall, LA Times, Nov 19, 2011

Companies not buying enough 'green' palm oil: WWF
By Staff Writers, AFP, Nov 22, 2011

Other Scientific News
China plans major effort in pursuing manned space technology
By Staff Writers, XNA, Nov 22, 2011

Multidisciplinary team of researchers develop world's lightest material
By Staff Writers, SPX, Nov 21, 2011

Other News that May Be of Interest
Is sustainability science really a science
By Staff Writers, SPX, Nov 25, 2011

European iodine mystery solved
By Staff Writers, World Nuclear News, Nov 17, 2011

Honda Civic Natural Gas wins 2012 Green Car of the Year Award
By Susan Carpenter, LA Times, Nov 17, 2011
[SEPP Comment: According to the article, EPA gives it a 48 MPGe economy rating. This is better than the previous 31 MPG but still does not pass the future EPA standards. The list of the judges is revealing.]

Insured disaster
The insurance industry has been behind the global-warming fraud since the 1970s
By Lawrence Solomon, Financial Post, Nov 18, 2011 [H/t GWPF]

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Caribou supposedly roasted by global warming found unharmed
By Anthony Watts, WUWT, Nov 24, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Over 250,000 missing caribou suddenly re-appear! Is it proof of creationism?]

Climate Minister buys a castle with 16 bathrooms... and a massive carbon footprint
By Victoria Allen and Tamara Cohen, Mail Online, Nov 18,2011
[SEPP Comment: We each have to fight climate change in our own way!]

Climategate 2.0: the Warmists' seven stages of grief.
By James Delingpole, The Telegraph, UK, Nov 23, 2011

Erratic, extreme day-to-day weather puts climate change in new light
By Staff Writers, SPX, Nov 21, 2011
[SEPP Comment: Given the tremendous increase of number and sensitivity of instrumentation, it is probably impossible to establish an earlier

You are now being logged in using your Facebook credentials