Written by IPT News
The Michigan-based separatist movement lured followers with an explosive mixture of radical religious interpretation and a deep hostility toward government, especially law enforcement.
It trained in the use of weapons and talked of killing police officers.
After building a criminal case, federal law enforcement officials prepared to move in. The suspects all were considered armed and dangerous. FBI agents lured them to a site away from their base of operations in hopes they could be arrested peacefully. The defendants could live to fight in court.
At this point, we could be describing the March arrests of nine members of the Hutaree, a Christian terrorist movement whose members are charged with seditious conspiracy, or the October case of Imam Luqman Abdullah and 11 followers on conspiracy and weapons charges.
The arrests have one significant and tragic difference. All the Hutaree suspects surrendered when agents came to arrest them, one after a lengthy standoff, and no one was hurt. But Abdullah was killed after refusing to surrender and firing his gun as FBI agents moved in. One of three shots fired from Abdullah's gun killed a police dog sent in to subdue him.
An autopsy report shows he was shot 20 times, all between the chest and thigh. As we've noted, Abdullah supporters have tried to cast the shooting as an excessive, unjust reaction. The most recent iteration of that campaign came this week, as the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) Michigan office released a handful of pictures from that autopsy.
Two showed him face down and handcuffed. Another showed wounds to his face that may have come from the dog. "There are a lot of questions, and the photos raise more questions," said Dawud Walid, executive director of CAIR-Michigan.
Walid also released a letter from State Representative Bettie Cook Scott, which tried to cast the peaceful arrest of the Hutaree suspects as proof the FBI botched the Abdullah shooting:
"David Stone and the Hutaree militia were advocating violence. They were observed firing weapons, constructing explosive devices, as well as preparing a detailed plan to kill law enforcement officers. The FBI response was to arrest David Stone and his cohorts.
These differences in the application of lethal force are unacceptable. Our country and our government must be held accountable for its actions. American people regardless of race, creed, or color are entitled to the same constitutional guarantees. The FBI use of lethal force must equally apply to all operations."
Scott would have a point had Stone or any other Hutaree member fired at the agents as they moved in and had agents not returned fire. But that's not what happened.
Most media reports cited CAIR's belief that the pictures "raise questions," but don't seem to push back about Abdullah's violent rhetoric or reports that he got off as many as three shots before he died. ABC News' report was co-written by Sharaf Mowjood, a former government relations manager for CAIR's Los Angeles office. Of all the stories written about the autopsy photographs, the CAIR-Michigan homepage links to this one.
The story quotes the FBI Detroit Special Agent in Charge saying his agents "did what they had to do to protect themselves" and followed that with Walid asking "How could he be so sure?"
For starters, there are the reports of all the agents at the scene, the autopsy, ballistics from Abdullah's gun and the fact that four suspects in the warehouse where Abdullah died surrendered as instructed and were not harmed.
Walid's campaign should be viewed in context of an ongoing feud between the FBI and CAIR. The FBI broke off outreach communications with CAIR in 2008, based on evidence in a Texas terror-financing trial which showed CAIR's founders, including current Executive Director Nihad Awad, were part of U.S.-based Hamas support network. The Department of Justice has been resolute in defending prosecutors' decision to name CAIR as an unindicted co-conspirator in the case.
Meanwhile, Walid's criticisms ignore the issue of Abdullah's choice not to surrender or lay down his weapon. He emphasizes the number of shots fired by the FBI and the fact that the dog, Freddy, was airlifted for medical help before he died and Abdullah was not.
He still clings to the notion that Abdullah may have been unarmed:
"We don't know if he had a weapon or not, but most people, if they're being mauled by a dog and they have a (gun), they're not going to think about whether they're going to be shot," Walid said. "Their imminent threat would be the dog."
Abdullah was not dangerous, Walid said, regardless of his rhetoric.
Detroit News reporter Paul Egan dug into Abdullah's 1980 arrest, which is mentioned in the original complaint, and found that he had tried to kill an officer at least once before. Abdullah struggled with an officer during a traffic stop and later told another officer, "I should have killed him."
Walid acknowledged the episode "doesn't sound very positive," but "I don't know if that would correlate to the incident that took place in October of 2009."
Walid's response to overwhelming evidence is about as sophisticated as a child sticking his fingers in his ears and shouting "na-na-na-na-na..." when he doesn't want to hear something he doesn't like.
Investigators had inside accounts of Abdullah's operations from a former follower-turned-informant. The informant told investigators he repeatedly heard "Abdullah preach that Islam should be spread through violent jihad, and advocate violence against the government and against law enforcement." Abdullah vowed to respond violently if police tried to arrest him or take him weapons.
Unless the government is lying, Abdullah is heard on tape giving a 2004 sermon, instructing followers not to "carry a pistol if you're going to give it up to police. You give them a bullet."
Hutaree leader David Stone wanted to kill cops, too. His plot involved killing an officer at a traffic stop, then ambushing the dozens of officers from throughout the region who would attend the slain cop's funeral. In a transcript of a recording made by an FBI undercover agent, he explained part of the rationale:
"You kill enough cops... you can't get enough people to take the job."
The cases bear striking similarities. Law enforcement in Detroit clearly has its hands full in combating potentially violent extremists. It's not the FBI's fault that one guy chose to practice what he preached about facing police. CAIR's continuing attempt to deflect all responsibility away from Luqman Abdullah with its campaign of "questions" in the absence of anything more than conjecture speaks volumes about its priorities.
The Investigative Project on Terrorism (IPT) is a non-profit research group founded by Steven Emerson in 1995. It is recognized as the world's most comprehensive data center on radical Islamic terrorist groups.