Written by Dr Laffer
AUSTIN-The health care reform plans pending in the U.S. Congress would cause more harm than good, according to a study released today by internationally renowned economist Dr. Arthur Laffer.
"Health care reform along the lines proposed by President Obama and currently pending in Congress would render U.S. citizens poorer and their federal and state governments sorely pressed for revenues," Laffer said. "But just as important, these reforms are not a cost-effective way to expand health insurance coverage, one of the primary goals of reform."
Full Report Download
According to Dr. Laffer, legislation that provided an additional $1 trillion in federal health care spending would increase health care costs and medical price inflation, slow our national economy, and still leave 30 million Americans uninsured.
In his paper for the Texas Public Policy Foundation, "The Prognosis for National Health Insurance" (www.LafferHealthCareReport.org), Dr. Laffer urges Congress to work toward a solution that will not penalize the 70 percent of Americans who currently are happy with their health care arrangements, and that will not increase the federal deficit while only reducing the number of uninsured Americans by roughly one-third. Instead, Laffer emphasizes the need for patient-centered reform.
The study indicates that reforms need to focus on reducing costs by closing what Dr. Laffer has coined the "health care wedge" - a separation of effort and reward by which a patient understands the true costs of their health care and is therefore driven to be more efficient in his or her spending. This separation is actually the reason health care costs are skyrocketing, according to Dr. Laffer.
"When the government spends money on health care, the patient does not," says Dr. Laffer. "The patient is then separated from the transaction in the sense that costs are no longer his concern. Health care reform should be based on policies that diminish this wedge rather than increase it."
Health care costs have risen over the past 50 years, while the patient's out-of-pocket contribution has plummeted: half of all medical expenditures in 1950 were paid by patients in the form of out-of-pocket expenses; today only 10 percent of expenditures are paid the same way.
Dr. Laffer's research concluded that the current proposals being discussed in Washington would:
Dr. Laffer says there are many solutions available to better the health care system without destroying what already is good in the system. The path to true health care reform is through patient-centered solutions, which emphasize the patient-doctor relationship and work to shrink the wedge by allowing patients and doctors to make more effective and economical health care choices. These solutions include:
The full report may be downloaded at www.LafferHealthCareReport.org. Starting next week, information will be added that details the impact of the proposed legislation to several key states.
Dr. Arthur Laffer provides economic research and consulting to institutional asset managers, pension funds, financial institutions, policy research organizations and corporations. He is the creator of the "Laffer Curve," an innovation that earned him the distinction as the "Father of Supply-Side Economics." He was a member of President Reagan's Economic Policy Advisory Board for both of his terms.
The Texas Public Policy Foundation is a non-profit, free-market research institute based in Austin. More information on the Foundation can be found at www.texaspolicy.com.
Director of Media and Government Relations
Texas Public Policy Foundation